Sue said....."But you said that you were using MFW for high school and SCM for the younger ones anyway so I don't understand why you are worried about SCM's high school."
I'm not.:-) What I was meaning, was the fact that this woman's daughter had read the SCM h.s. books in elementary was making me question the rigor of SCM in general for elementary with my younger 6 kids.
Yes I was pretty much decided on MFW for h.s. so it was the younger years that
had me concerned. I do know now that she was referring to the MFW "book basket" concept where up to 300 books are listed in the TM and this is where the daughter gleaned and read the SCM h.s. books.