SCM Discussion Forum

1. 

   deltagal
   Member

   Was it CM that suggested a mother should have 3 or so books going at a time?  If so, what were the genres and where does she speak of this.  Thank you.

   Posted 1 year ago # Report Post
2. 

   jawgee
   Member

   I can't seem to find a specific passage where this was mentioned, but it does sound like a CM principle.

   We usually have several read-alouds going at one time.

   -one or two history read-alouds (a spine and a separate book about the specific historical event we're studying)
   -a nature read-aloud about the season or an animal we're studying
   -a literature read-aloud (in our family, this is with Daddy at bedtime)
   -perhaps a biography of the artist or composer we're learning about, with only a few pages read each week
   -a faith or religion book, such as Bible stories, a book about character, a saint biography, etc.

   Posted 1 year ago # Report Post
3. 

   suzukimom
   Member

   I'm pretty sure I remember reading this too... but can't remember if it was in a book BY CM or one ABOUT CM.....

   I can't remember the details either (must not have narrated it to anyone... lol)   but I don't think it was Genre's exactly... more like 

   One to Inspire, one to learn from, and one to entertain.... although that last one doesn't sound quite right either....

   Posted 1 year ago # Report Post
4. 

   jawgee
   Member

   Oh, interesting. I've never heard the inspire, learn, entertain idea. I'd love to hear more of where that came from.

   Posted 1 year ago # Report Post
5. 

   MamaSnow
   Member

   I think it may have been Karen Andreola who popularized the notion of having three different books going at a time...but I'm not entirely sure. FWIW...

   Posted 1 year ago # Report Post
6. 

   suzukimom
   Member

   Ah yes, in 

   A Charlotte Mason Companion by Karen Andreola, on page 346 (in the Chapter on Mother Culture) recommends

   1. A Stiff Book (ie, a challenging one)
   2. A Moderately easy book (ie a biography)
   3. A Novel (preferably good ones - not twaddle.  examples included George Eliot, Charles Dickens, etc)

   and you can pick up the one you "feel fit for" at that time

   she also quoted Charlotte Mason, "Never be without a good book on hand"

   so yes, the 3 books was from Karen Andreola 

   Posted 1 year ago # Report Post
7. 

   deltagal
   Member

   Marvelous.  I thought it might be Karen Andreola if it wasnt' CM (or Susan Schaeffer Mc...), but couldn't find it when I skimmed the CM Companion last night, so I posted the questiion. Thank you.  I'm just making a book list for myself for the new year and thought I would use this guideline.  so, here's the next question.    What books would you recommend that are  stiff, moderately easy and a novel?

    

   Posted 1 year ago # Report Post
8. 

   jawgee
   Member

   To pick specific books, I recommend you look at some booklists - either on the Free Curriculum Guide on this site, Ambleside Online, or Mater Amabilis:

   http://amblesideonline.org/
   http://materamabilis.org/

   See what appeals to you and your children.

   Posted 1 year ago # Report Post
9. 

   deltagal
   Member

   Yes, thank you.  I'm specifically thinking in the  Mother Culture vein about books for myself to read. 

   Posted 1 year ago # Report Post
10. 

    Tristan
    Member

    To me stiff books could be classics like by authors like Jane Austen or something that is personally challenging you to make changes (like a book on prayer life, organization, or scripture study) maybe C.S.Lewis? What about Charlotte Mason's original series?

    One thing I would love to do some year (LOL) is choose an author who has written several books and read them all over the year.

    Under a novel books like the Anne of Green Gables series come to mind. Maybe something by G.A. Henty? though his could fit in other categories for me, they take brain-power to read.

    Posted 1 year ago # Report Post
11. 

    MamaSnow
    Member

    Well, I always have a handful of books going. =) Right now they are:

    Charlotte Mason's Original Home Education (I'd consider this a "stiff" book)
    The Discipline of Grace (Not necessarily an "easy" read, but inspirational)
    Mansfield Park (Jane Austen) - novel

    and of course always the Bible...reading out of Joshua and Proverbs for myself, Genesis and Mark with the kiddos. Sometimes dh and I like to read something together too, but we aren't at the moment.

    I also like to read kids' books just for myself...not always with the kids. =) I think part of what drew me to a CM education was the fact that it would allow me to continue to dabble in my lifelong love for excellent children's literature. =)

    HTH
    Jen

    Posted 1 year ago # Report Post
12. 

    suzukimom
    Member

    There were some specific suggestions in the Charlotte Mason Companion...  (and yes, the Bible is supposed to be going as well...)

    I have to say that the Anne of Green Gables books and others by L.M. Montgommery would be wonderful novels.... but as a Canadian I might be biased.

    Posted 1 year ago # Report Post
13. 

    deltagal
    Member

    Oh, this is all so helpful, everyone.  Thank you!  I always have a bunch of books going, but I wanted to think my list for 2012 through in a different way.  Some of the books I have on my list for 2012 include the Miss Read books, The Country Diary of an Edwardian Lady, Jane Eyre, Square Foot Gardening,  Letters from Eden, The Weekend Garden Guide, Book 4 of CM's series, From Clutter to Clarity by Twig, Natchez by Harnett Kane, Savoring God's Word by Jan Johnson, Reading with Deeper Eyes by William Willimon, a study of the Book of James, Parenting is Heart Work by Turansky and Miller, Lessons from Blackberry Inn by Andreola, .  I'm pulling titles (and ordering a few) and putting them in the crate under my bed, so I'll have my collection ready to go.  Keep those titles and thoughts coming!

    Posted 1 year ago # Report Post
14. 

    botanicalbecky
    Member

    I'm impressed with your thinking-ahead-ness! I really should try to make a list like that, then maybe I wouldn't end up where I am today - bookless! I'm in need of a novel, but nothing has jumped out at me yet. I'm thinking maybe another by Kate Morton.

    Have fun with your list!

    Posted 1 year ago # Report Post
15. 

    ebcsmom
    Member

    When do you all have time to keep all of these books going? I have 3 little ones 9 and under, and we usually keep 2-3 read aloud books going plus our bible. I don't usually have time to keep 3 books going for myself especially if I am going to keep my chores up, cook from scratch and keep things going outside the house as well. I wish I had more time to sit down with a book, but it seems like after Im done with their read alouds which is usually 2 hours or more a day, Ive got lots of other things in the home that need tending. I like to keep a very tidy house as well.   So when do you find the time?? What does a normal schedule look like time wise for you?

    Posted 1 year ago # Report Post

RSS feed for this topic

Reply »

You must log in to post.